An open letter
I read this today. http://thingstodoindelhi.com/ and hence this.
An open letter to all my friends who think it's cool to bash cities like Delhi or Bangalore or Mumbai or Kolkata.
This isn't new, and strangely, horribly, it is growing like weed we are not able to control. On some days, it pops up as a real long post from a girl who is commenting on the moral code of the male specimens from the other city, to which an equally long post from the “other city” emerges out in no time. On some days, it is the “trending topic” on twitter, where people bash the other cities shamelessly, and even proudly. I am now writing this with a confession that I have been a part of this bashing too. But this post is about how I got into this mud slinging drama, with the very literate, but not-so-educated inhabitants of the New India.
I was born and lived in Delhi all through the first quarter of my life. All this while, I always heard with reverence, the stories of people who were living near the south shores of my country. My father, used to tell me, they were extremely hard working people and great intellectuals. Leading a simple lifestyle and contributing to India's scientific heritage. I would be lying, if I were to say, that I didn't want to become APJ Abdul Kalam or Narayan Murty, who almost calmly brought upon a new resurgent wave of entrepreneurship in India.
Later, as I was growing up, I could hear stories of near and far cousins who went to Bangalore to participate in the technology boom, whose epicenter was right in the heart of Bangalore. They spoke about the heavenly weather, and the delicious food.
All these stories went straight to my subconscious and were forgotten till the day, when I came to know that I got admission in a reputed design school in Bangalore. I then heard how Bangalore had emerged as a unique cosmopolitan city in India, allowing people irrespective of the caste, religion or patronage to flock here and make a living, an intellectual living based on merit.
I fell in love with Bangalore the moment I stepped foot on its soil. The weather is just so good, I was at a place where I could get soulful of idli's and other yummy Karnataka food. I never felt out of place in this city. I was out of my home for the first time, and made Bangalore my home. With my new found freedom, it gave me a whole new set of goals and meanings to achieve them.
I am not the person who wants to belong to a geographical location to derive her value system, it doesn't matter to me. Yet, the reality that you accompany some of the characteristics of the people you share your life with, cannot be altered completely.
Yet, I had the shock of my life, when some my friends at my college, started bashing Delhi almost on a daily basis. It was open and heavy during classes and then in the chai time breaks. How the people in Delhi are rude and how they are all rapists and how tacky their behaviour is in public transport. It went on and on to no end. I was agreeing to a lot of such allegations and so-called factual remarks, and they didn't make a difference to me. But, when they continued to no end, that's when my patience gave away.
Delhi, or any other city in India, or for that matter, the world cannot be spoken as one entity. Simply because it is NOT. The times when you could speak of a group of people having the same ideals about life has evolved. Delhi is simply now, a potpourri of cultures and people. There is a presence of every small and big community in Delhi and they have carried on with their own rituals, and Delhi has accepted it. It has to. So, it goes for the any other city in India. Will Bangalore reject all the workers who come from Madhya Pradhesh and Bihar to lay the foundation of Multinational IT parks and companies? I don't think so.
And is everybody in Bangalore an entrepreneur? Working in an IT company? Does everybody in Bangalore has idly sambhar all the time? As breakfast, lunch and dinner?
This kind of a generalization only shows how shallow your facts are. How you have easily fell into the trap of general comments which are simply overheard or passed down at Chai stalls and friendly gatherings, as personal experiences, which would be fatal if you were to accept it as a rule, and not as an experience.
It is more fatal when people start not only believing it, but spread it assertively.
In its creative ways, it is indeed healthy to recognize the fallacies of people and their irresponsible behavior, but is it indeed healthy to go all about it, to hurt people as well? Delhi is way too rowdy to hold a rock concert, but its theaters are also full when Anoushka Shankar decides to perform. Also, Sambhar is not the only heavenly dish in Bangalore, but there are hundreds of gems ready to explode as a gastric delight in your mouth, in every morsel.
Also, to readers, who are now thinking of writing to me an insecure blogger who's just wrapping all this in a pretension of covering up the sins her city commits every hour. I want to point everyone to a place where I am so sure you wouldn't have taken the pain to visit, else such spiteful and irrelevant remarks wouldn't have emerged out of your facebook profiles or tweets.
This is a link to National Crime Records Bureau of India, I would urge you to download the Crime statistics report.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_in_India#Crime_by_locale
and http://ncrb.nic.in/ and go through a real reading of the statistics
Also, a warning to NOT believe even the above mentioned stats
http://lawandotherthings.blogspot.in/2011/12/indias-unknown-crime-rate.html
And in the end, if you cannot change the situation a bit, kindly refrain from spreading hatred and anxiety in other people, who feel insecure in their own country because of ignorantly-assertive people like you.
Peace.
A Delhi-and-Bangalore lover.
